Top 5 Shelter Island Homes for Less Than $3 Million

Top 5 Shelter Island Homes for Less Than $3 Million

One of the great things about being surrounded by water is all those waterfront properties and water views. Shelter Island, conveniently located between the North and South forks and only accessible by ferry—or private boat—is a quiet and beautiful place with unbelievable real estate opportunities.

  • 1 Landing Lane, Shelter Island

    1 Landing Lane, Shelter Island. $2,795,000

    This newly built waterfront 4-bedroom Traditional located in a private community has a pool and dock. On 1.02 acres, the 2,774-square-foot residence have 5 baths, a detached garage outfitted with solar panels, a basement media room with sliding doors to the patio, a master bedroom suite on the waterside with a deck and a waterside living room.

  • 2 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island.  $2,800,000

    2 Bay Avenue, Shelter Island. $2,800,000

    On .66 acres, this 2,968-square-foot waterfront Colonial has 6 bedrooms and 3.5 baths. Enjoy a dock and gazebo. The Florida sunroom fills with light and the living room has a fireplace. The home is in Montclair Colony.

  • 37D Westmoreland Drive, Shelter Island. $2,990,000

    37D Westmoreland Drive, Shelter Island. $2,990,000

    This Nantucket is 5,400 square feet on 1.4 acres., bordering a historic farm and a 40-acre preserve. Named Folded Wings, the residence is on the harborfront. It is custom built with private wings. The foyer has a skylight and curved staircase. There are 4 bedrooms and 7 baths on the property, and more rooms including a parlor, office, family room, laundry room, formal dining room, living room with fireplace and panoramic water views, kitchen with hearth, island, wet bar, granite counter and dining area, and sunroom with wet bar. There are 300 feet of shoreline and the property has a 2-story dockhouse with kitchenette, full bath and living quarters with water views.

  • 64 Gardiners Bay Drive, Shelter Island.  $2,995,000

    64 Gardiners Bay Drive, Shelter Island. $2,995,000

    This Traditional beach house is 3,530 square feet on 0.91 acres. Located on Gardiners Bar, the residence has 3 bedrooms and 4 baths. The foyer leads to the kitchen with granite counters, high-end applianced and waterview breakfast area; a library with built-in bookcases; living and dining areas that overlook the water and have a fireplace and a sunroom facing the beach and waterside deck access with views of Big Light lighthouse. Among the amenities are a spa-like bath with steam show and built-in wardrobe.

  • 47, 45, 58D and 58E Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island

    47, 45, 58D and 58E Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island. $2,999,000

    On 2.01 acres, this 2,388-square-foot Traditional beach house has 4 bedrooms and 3.5 baths and sunset water views with two sandy beachfront parcels on Peconic Bay. The open design has vaulted ceilings with natural light pouring into the living room, dining room, custom kitchen and master bedroom suite and a den/bedroom on the main floor. The 2nd floor has 2 ensuite bedrooms, a family room, a sitting room and a deck. Amenities inclide a specious deck, a garage and a waterside gunite pool surrounded by stone.

BACK TO The Top 5

You must be logged in to vote.