Top Five Homes For Sale on Shelter Island Under $3 Mil

It’s a dream to live on a beautiful island and you can do it by buying on one of the most beautiful islands in AmericaShelter Island provides a unique ownership opportunity because it is away from the glitz and glam of the Hamptons, and provides a more easy-going atmosphere and unpresedented beauty. This week our Top Five showcases the best properties for sale on this wonderful island under $3 million.

Live the Dream, $2,950,000

This four bedroom three bath traditional is located harborfront on Shelter Island and has everything you could possibly need. Situated on 1.11 acres with sprawling lawns leading right to the water and the 100-foot deep water dock. Light and bright, other amenities include a fully finished lower level featuring a 10-seat screening room, full bar area, and large wine room with tasting area. A newly renovated kitchen leads to separate dining area, and stone patios surround the private pool area gorgeous sunsets complete this amazing property.

Waterfront Perfection, $2,795,000

Offering spectacular views of West Neck Bay, this 4-bedroom, 4-bath home is constructed with the utmost quality and details throughout. The first floor features an open layout with living room, gourmet kitchen, dining room with waterviews and 1 bedroom, 1 bath. The second floor boasts 3 bedrooms including the waterside master suite and den. Two bedrooms have waterside deck access. The finished lower level offers a full bath and a large recreation room with large door leading to waterside.  This property is complete with a heated Gunite pool and large 2 car garage with studio space above. Solar panels keep electric bills to a minimum.

Unique, $2,795,000

This is a unique offering–spacious waterfront home with panoramic harbor and preserve views and Gunite pool in grandfathered location overlooking dock. idyllic setting for leisurely times…This contemporary saltbox is bright and spacious, with double height ceilings throughout the living room with fireplace and dining area. There are two cheery sunrooms, one with fireplace. The kitchen, recently updated, has custom cabinets and granite countertops with attractive breakfast bar. The master suite offers gorgeous water views and its own deck. Just off the foyer is an en-suite bedroom. The second floor has three additional guest bedrooms, joined by a balcony overlooking the living room.

Magnificent, $2,600,000

This magnificent Victorian residence c.1883 presides on three quarters of an acre with 108 feet of water frontage westerly facing views on Dering Harbor. The property boasts original period details everywhere, a relaxing wrap-around covered porch, and a rolling lawn down to a most graceful waterfront setting where the potential for a deep water dock awaits the next owner. Inside is a meandering floor plan of room after room- a country kitchen and butlers room, formal dining room, living room with fireplace which opens on to the front porch, and a parlor with its own porch.

Chic Retreat, $2,500,000

A unique and private setting in South Ferry Hills overlooking spectacular waterviews of Annies Creek and bordering Mashomack Preserve.  This state of the art traditional home with a modern twist has an open kitchen, dining area, leading to great room with soaring ceilings and floor to ceiling fireplace. Gallery above with library. This four bedroom, three bath home has a finished lower level for entertainment and access to pool area. Pool house and Gunite pool complete this special property. Exclusive.

More from Our Sister Sites