Top Five Homes for Rent on Shelter Island this Summer

Shelter Island provides a unique rental opportunity away from the glitz and glam of the Hamptons. It’s far more easy going and always a lot of fun. This week, our Top Five showcases the best properties for summer rental on Shelter Island.

Bumblebee Manor, MD-LD, $275,000

Unlike any property on the East End, the panoramic water views are outstanding. There is an infinity pool on the waterside flanked by a recreation pavilion and the original home is beautifully appointed. Unquestionably one of the finest properties in the region, this luxurious waterfront estate is nothing short of majestic. Exquisitely positioned directly on the water, this extraordinary residential compound is sited on 3.25 acres comprising lush gardens, rolling lawns, over 300 feet of private beach frontage, as well as a deep water dock that can accommodate a large yacht, helicopter and seaplane.

Spacious Shelter Island Waterfront, MD-LD, $175,000

Spend your summer in the ultimate waterfront! With lots of room for everyone, southern views on the water, 5 bedrooms, 5.5 baths, chef’s kitchen, high ceilings throughout, waterside balconies in most bedrooms, lower level above grade, with common room, office, first floor TV room and deepwater dock. This is a very special house on the water on Shelter Island!

Modern and Beautiful, MD-LD, $150,000

This lovely home is waiting for you to enjoy. It has 5 bedrooms and amazing bay views. The property is fully landscaped with a heated pool. The house was built by one of the Hamptons‘ finest builders and no detail was left out.

Private Compund, MD-LD: $125,000

Secluded family compound with main house and carriage house on 3.8 acres in an estate section. The main house has 3 bedrooms an attached office, 2.5 baths, living room, dining room, family room, library, sunroom, kitchen with 2 dishwashers. Kitchen has a Viking stove and there is central air conditioning. The carriage house has 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, living room/dining room, kitchen with dishwasher.

On the Bay, MD-LD, $115,000

Gorgeous new construction with every amenity. Perfect for entertaining friends and family by the bay. Tastefully furnished with welcoming layout featuring living room with vaulted ceiling and stone fireplace, waterside dining room and gourmet granite kitchen.

More from Our Sister Sites