South Fork: Food & Drink Dan’s Best of the Best 2014 Winners

BAGELS

Platinum
Goldberg’s Bagels
801 Country Rd 39, Southampton
631-204-1046

Gold
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main St, Southampton
631-283-6949

Silver
Hampton Bagels 
74 N Main Street, East Hampton
631-324-5411

Bronze
Bagel Buoy
3 Bay Street, Sag Harbor
631-725-7690

BAKERY

Platinum
Citarella
20 Hampton Road, Southampton
2209 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
2 Pantigo Road, East Hampton
631-537-5990

Gold
Tate’s Bake Shop
43 N Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-9830

Silver
Krieg’s Bakery
39 Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-728-6524

Bronze
Blue Duck Bakery
30 Hampton Road, Southampton
631-204-1701

BEER

Platinum
Southampton Publick House
40 Bowden Sq, Southampton
631-283-2800

Gold
Montauk Brewing Company
62 S Erie Ave, Montauk
631-668-8471

Silver
Buckley’s Inn Between
139 W Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-728-7197

Bronze
Mercado
1970 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
631-237-1334

Bronze
Rumba 
43 Canoe Place Road, Hampton Bays
631-594-3544

BREWERY

Platinum
Southampton Publick House
40 Bowden Sq, Southampton
631-283-2800

Gold
Montauk Brewing Company
62 S Erie Ave, Montauk
631-668-8471

Silver
Greenport Harbor Brewing Co.
234 Carpenter St, Greenport
631-477-6681

Bronze
Moustache Brewing Co.
400 Hallett Avenue, Riverhead
631-591-3250

BRICK-OVEN PIZZA         

Platinum
Pellegrino’s
1271 Noyack Road, Southampton
631-283-9742

Gold
World Pie
2402 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
631-537-7999

Silver
Serafina
104 North Main Street, East Hampton
631-267-3500

Bronze
Doppio
126 Main Street, Sag Harbor
631-808-3444

BURGERS       

Platinum
75 Main
75 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-7575

Gold
Boom Burger
85 Montauk Hwy, Westhampton Beach
631-998-4663

Silver
1 North Steakhouse
322 W Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-594-3419

Bronze
The Driver’s Seat
62 Jobs Lane, Southampton
631-283-6606

BUTCHER

Platinum
Justin’s Chop Shop
214 Mill Road, Westhampton Beach
631-288-5532

Gold
Citarella
2209 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
631-537-5990

Silver
Schmidt’s
1282 North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-1212

Bronze
Cromer’s Market
3500 Noyac Rd, Sag Harbor
631-725-9087

CANDY STORE    

Platinum
The Candied Anchor
721 Montauk Highway, Montauk
631-668-8038

Gold
Buddha Berry
125 Main Street, Sag Harbor
631-808-3888

Silver
Fudge n’ Stuff
41 S Edgemere St, Montauk
631-668-4724

Bronze
Dylan’s Candy Bar
52 Main Street, East Hampton
631-324-6181

CAPPUCCINO

Platinum
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-6949

Gold
Hampton Coffee Co.
869 Montauk Highway, Water Mill
631-726-2633

Silver
Coffee Tauk
83 S Elmwood Avenue, Montauk
631-668-7007

Bronze
Sant Ambroeus
30 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-1233

CHEESE SHOP

Platinum
Citarella
2209 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
631-537-5990

Gold
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main St, Southampton
631-283-6949

Silver
Cavaniola’s Gourmet Cheese Shop
89 Division St, Sag Harbor
631-725-0095

Bronze
Mecox Farms
19 Horsemill Lane, Bridgehampton
631-537-6154

CLAM BAKE

Platinum
Lobster Grille Inn
162 Inlet Road, Southampton
631-283-1525

Gold
Cor-J
36 Lighthouse Road, Hampton Bays
631-728-5186

Silver
Clamman Seafood Market
235 N Sea Rd, Southampton
631-283-6437

Bronze
Stuart’s Seafood
41 Oak Ln, Amagansett
631-267-6700

CLAM CHOWDER

Platinum
Westlake Fish House
352 W Lake Drive, Montauk
631-668-3474

Gold
Shuckers Lobster Bar
58 Foster Avenue, Hampton Bays

Silver
Canal Café
44 Newtown Road, Hampton Bays
631-723-2155

Bronze
Tully’s Hampton Bays
78 Foster Ave, Hampton Bays
631-728-9043

COCKTAIL 

Platinum
75 Main
75 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-7575

Gold
The American Hotel
49 Main St, Sag Harbor
631-725-3535

Silver
Rumba
43 Canoe Place Rd, Hampton Bays
631-594-3544

Bronze
Cowfish
258 E Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-594-3868

COFFEE

Platinum
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-6949

Gold
Hampton Coffee Co.
869 Montauk Highway, Water Mill
631-726-2633

Silver
CoffeeTauk
83 S Elmwood Avenue, Montauk
631-668-7007

Bronze
Tate’s Bake Shop
43 North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-9830

COOKIES

Platinum
Tate’s Bake Shop
43 North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-9830

Gold
Ye Olde Bake Shop
17 Windmill Lane, Southampton
631-283-6553

Silver
Blue Duck Bakery
30 Hampton Rd, Southampton
631-204-1701

Bronze
Cafe Oso @ Southampton Inn
91 Hill Street, Southampton
631-283-1166

CUPCAKES

Platinum
Coffee Tauk
83 S Elmwood Avenue, Montauk
631-668-7007

Gold
Mary’s Marvelous
207 Main St, Amagansett
631-267-8796

Silver
Blue Duck Bakery
30 Hampton Rd, Southampton
631-204-1701

Silver
Ye Olde Bake Shop
17 Windmill Lane, Southampton
631-283-6553

Bronze
Sugar Sugar Custom Cakes
77 Main St, Westhampton Beach
631-288-2947

DESSERTS       

Platinum
75 Main
75 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-7575

Gold
Boom Burger
85 Montauk Hwy, Westhampton Beach
631-998-4663

Silver
Tate’s Bake Shop
43 N Sea Rd, Southampton
631-283-9830

Bronze
Blue Duck Bakery
30 Hampton Rd, Southampton
631-204-1701

Bronze
Pierre’s 
2468 Main Street, Bridgehampton
631-537-5110

FARMERS MARKET

Platinum
Westhampton Beach

Gold
Sag Harbor

Silver
Southampton

FARMERS MARKET VENDOR

Platinum
Mecox Dairy
855 Mecox Road, Water Mill
631-537-035

Gold
Horman’s Best Pickles 

Silver
Boathouse Road

Bronze
Sweet Andy’s Cookies

FARM STAND     

Platinum
Balsam Farms
Corner of Windmill Lane and Town Lane, Amagansett
631-316-8784

Gold
Halsey Farm Stand
513 Deerfield Road, Water Mill
631-726-4843

Silver
Round Swamp Farm
184 Three Mile Harbor Road, East Hampton
631-324-4438

Bronze
Green Thumb
829 Montauk Highway, Water Mill
631-726-1900

FRENCH FRIES   

Platinum
75 Main
75 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-7575

Gold
Boom Burger
85 Montauk Highway, Westhampton Beach
631-998-4663

Silver
The Driver’s Seat
62 Jobs Lane, Southampton
631-283-6606

Bronze
Rowdy Hall
62 Jobs Lane, Southampton
631-283-6606

FRIED CHICKEN

Platinum
Citarella
2209 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
631-537-5990

Gold
Cromer’s Market
3500 Noyac Rd, Sag Harbor
631-725-9087

Silver
Navy Beach
16 Navy Road, Montauk
631-668-6868

Bronze
The Cuddy
29 Main Street, Sag Harbor
631-725-0101

GOURMET FOOD SHOP 

Platinum
Citarella
2209 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
631-537-5990

Gold
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-6949

Silver
Schmidt’s
120 North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-5777

Bronze
East Hampton Gourmet
66 Newtown Lane, East Hampton
631-329-3993

Bronze
Luigi’s 
199 Pantigo Place, East Hampton
631-329-0558

GYRO   

Platinum
John Papas
18 Park Place, East Hampton
631-324-5400

Gold
Hamptons Greek Festival

Silver
Cromer’s Market
3500 Noyac Road, Sag Harbor
631-725-9087

Bronze
Princess Diner
32 Montauk Highway, Southampton
631-283-4255

HEALTH FOOD

Platinum
75 Main
75 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-7575

Gold
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-6949

Silver
Wild By Nature
260 W Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-723-3071

Bronze
Provisions
7 Main Street, Sag Harbor
631-725-3636

ICE CREAM

Platinum
Snowflake
1148 W Main Street, Riverhead
631-727-4394

Gold
Shock Ice Cream
99 Main Street, Westhampton Beach
631-288-2522

Silver
Coffee Tauk
83 S Elmwood Avenue, Montauk
631-668-7007

Bronze
Bay Burger-Joe & Liza’s
1742 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Tpke, Sag Harbor
631-899-3915

LIQUOR STORE     

Platinum
BottleHampton
850 County Rd 39, Southampton
631-353-3313

Gold
Hampton Bays Wine & Spirits
46 E Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-728-8595

Silver
Zabi’s
74 County Road 39, Southampton
631-287-7171

Bronze
McNamara’s
Bridgehampton Commons, 2044 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
631-537-1230

LOBSTER DINNER

Platinum
Shuckers Lobster Bar
58 Foster Avenue, Hampton Bays

Gold
Schmidt’s Seafood
1282 North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-1212

Gold
Clamman Seafood Market
235North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-6437

Silver
Hampton Lady
369 Dune Road, Hampton Bays
631-521-3366

LOBSTER ROLL   

Platinum
Canal Café
44 Newtown Road, Hampton Bays
631-723-2155

Gold
Bostwicks
277 Pantigo Road, East Hampton
631-324-1111

Silver
Lobster Roll/LUNCH
1980 Montauk Highway, Amagansett

Bronze
The Fish Farm 
429 Cranberry Hole Road, Amagansett
631-267-3341

Bronze
Clamman Seafood Market
235 N Sea Rd, Southampton
631-283-6437

LOCAL FLAVORED WATER 

Platinum
Hamptons H20

Gold
BAI 5

MUFFINS   

Platinum
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-6949

Gold
Tate’s Bake Shop
43 North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-9830

Silver
CoffeeTauk
83 S Elmwood Avenue, Montauk
631-668-7007

Bronze
Mary’s Marvelous 
207 Main St, Amagansett
631-267-8796
105-107 Newtown Lane, East Hampton
631-324-1055

Bronze
Cafe Oso at Southampton Inn
91 Hill Street, Southampton
631-283-1166

PIZZA

Platinum
Citarella
2209 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
631-537-5990

Gold
Edgewater
295 E Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-723-2323

Silver
La Parmigiana
44-48 Hampton Rd, Southampton
631-283-8030

Bronze
Paul’s Restaurant
21 Hill Street, Southampton
631-283-1861

RAW BAR 

Platinum
Shuckers Lobster Bar
58 Foster Avenue, Hampton Bays

Gold
Westlake Fish House
352 W Lake Drive, Montauk
631-668-3474

Silver
Clamman Seafood Market
235 N Sea Rd, Southampton
631-283-6437

Bronze
Harbor Raw Bar & Lounge
440 W Lake Drive, Montauk
631-668-8260

SALAD BAR

Platinum
Citarella
2209 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
631-537-5990

Gold
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-6949

Silver
Schmidt’s 
120 North Sea Road, Southampton
631-283-5777

SMOOTHIE     

Platinum
Village Gourmet Cheese Shoppe
11 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-6949

Gold
Second Nature Market
70 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-8117

Silver
Provisions
7 Main Street, Sag Harbor
631-725-3636

Bronze
Juice Press
93 Main Street, Southampton
631-488-4688

STEAK

Platinum
75 Main
75 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-7575

Gold
1 North Steakhouse
322 W Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-594-3419

Silver
The Driver’s Seat
62 Jobs Lane, Southampton
631-283-6606

Bronze
The Palm
94 Main St, East Hampton
631-324-0411

SUMMER DRINK 

Platinum
75 Main Cosmo
75 Main Street, Southampton
631-283-7575

Gold
Cocomo at The Driver’s Seat
62 Jobs Lane, Southampton
631-283-6606

Silver
Rumba’s Passion Fruit Colada
43 Canoe Place Road, Hampton Bays
631-594-3544

Bronze
Raspberry Limeade at The Driver’s Seat
62 Jobs Lane, Southampton
631-283-6606

SUSHI

Platinum
Citarella
2209 Montauk Hwy, Bridgehampton
631-537-5990

Gold
Westlake Fish House
352 W Lake Drive, Montauk
631-668-3474

Silver
Matsulin
131 W Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-728-8838

Bronze
Suki Zuki
688 Montauk Highway, Water Mill
631-726-4600

WINGS

Platinum
The Driver’s Seat
62 Jobs Lane, Southampton
631-283-6606

Gold
Boom Burger
85 Montauk Highway, Westhampton Beach
631-998-4663

Silver
Smokin’ Wolf
199 Pantigo Road, East Hampton
631-604-6470

Bronze
Buckley’s Inn Between
139 W Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
631-728-7197

View all 2014 Dan’s Best of the Best Categories