The Best of the Best Auto Body Repair Shops in the Hamptons and on the North Fork

fender bender
Get your vehicle to the Dan's Best of the Best Auto Body Repair Shop! Photo credit: monkeybusinessimages/iStock/Thinkstock

Who do you trust with your baby? Your car, that is.

When it comes to repairing scratches, dings, dents and fender benders, you want no less than the Best of the Best for your automobile. Dan’s Papers readers have voted on who they feel is tops on both the South and North forks. Here’s where to turn to get a vehicle as good as new again.

Randall’s Auto Body (277 David White’s Lane, Southampton, 631-283-9895) was voted the Platinum on the South Fork for Auto Body Repair Shop. Randall’s specializes in classic and hi-end vehicles and performs emergency auto repair as well as refurbishment of classic vehicles back to their factory specifications.

With more than half a century in the business, Suburban Auto Service (297 County Road 39, Southampton, 631-283-3095) took Gold, followed by Joe’s Garage (1426 North Sea Road, Southampton, 631-283-2098) with Silver and Corwith’s Auto Body (40 Willow Road, Water Mill, 631-726-2776) with Bronze.

On the North Fork, Starlite Auto Body (7255 Main Road, Mattituck, 631-298-5933) is the auto body shop that Dan’s readers ranked Platinum.

Ted’s Auto Body (37570 Route 25, Peconic, 631-734-5297), also called Ted’s Body & Fender Shop, follows with Gold. Rich’s Quality Auto Body (30 Pequash Avenue, Cutchogue, 631-734-7868) was voted Silver, and Lou’s Service Station (825 Pacific Street, Mattituck, 631-298-4066) ranked Bronze.

Find more of the Best of the Best auto services at

More from Our Sister Sites