Quantcast
Skip to content
Communities
  • North Fork
    • Jamesport
    • Mattituck
    • Orient
    • Riverhead
    • Shelter Island
    • Southold
  • The Hamptons
    • Montauk
    • Quogue
    • Sag Harbor
    • Sagaponack
    • Southampton
    • Water Mill
    • Westhampton Beach
  • NYC
  • Palm Beach
  • Home Pros
  • Digital Editions
  • Dan’s Best of the Best
  • Contact Us
  • RegisterLogin
Dan’s Papers
  • Things to Do

    Events Calendar

    View and Post Events

    • Books & Authors
    • Concerts
    • Comedy
    • Fairs & Festivals
    • Film
    • Fitness & Outdoors
    • Galleries & Museums
    • Kids & Families
    • LGBTQ+
    • Nonprofits & Philanthropy
    • Pets & Animals
    • Seasonal & Holiday
    • Shopping
    • Theater

    Dan’s Events

    Visit Dan’s Taste

  • Arts & Culture
    • Artist Profiles
    • Books & Authors
    • Galleries & Museums
    • Performing Arts
    • Music, Film & TV
  • Food & Drink
    • Recipes
    • Restaurants
    • Bars, Breweries & Distilleries
    • Wine & Wineries
  • Celebrity News
  • Local News
    • Crime & Police
    • Politics
    • Health
    • Business
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Obituaries
  • Real Estate
  • Lifestyle
    • Dan Rattiner’s Stories
    • Fashion & Style
    • Hotels & Inns
    • Kids & Family
    • Nonprofits & Philanthropy
    • Party & Event Photos
    • Wellness
Behind the Hedges

Transform this Waterfront Shelter Island Property into Your Dream House

By Laura Euler
1 minute 10/01/2018 Share

We were sort of bored by this listing (even though it’s waterfront) until we saw one thing. Sure, it’s waterfront on Coecles Harbor, which is pretty great. The house is circa 1900, but it’s being used as an artist’s studio, so we figured any interesting period details were gone.

Then we saw this and fell in love.

Close

Get the Full Story

News, events, culture and more — delivered to you.
Thank you for subscribing!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Ahhhhh. The house is small: 1500 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. But the plot size is a very generous 2.7 acres. You could easily expand to your heart’s content (keeping that fireplace), add a pool, whatever. Asking price for the property, repped by Seth Madore at Corcoran, is a reasonable $2 million.

What do you think? Worth it? Let us know in the comments.

For more, click here. 56 North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island

  • Vetted Hamptons Resources

    Hamptons Classified 

    Access our trusted network of local professionals and browse employment opportunities in the Hamptons.
    Find a Home Pro Search Jobs
  • Most Recent Articles

    Amagansett Beach & Bicycle

    Amagansett Beach and Bicycle Switches Gears with New Ownership

    Jewish tradition is clear: a genuine transfor mation does not happen overnight or for convenience.

    No Regrets

    Counterfeiting service cartoon by Dan Rattiner

    Gunfights in the Hamptons

    Robert H. Burns

    Robert H. Burns of Southampton Remembered as Leading Hotelier

  • Things to do on the East End

    More local events

    Cruise the Country Side: Wine, Orchards & Craft Beer by Bike

    East End Bike Tours
    Tomorrow, 10 am

    “EXPLORATIONS” Marilyn Stevenson Solo Exhibit

    The Water Mill Museum
    Tomorrow, 11 am

    Custom House in Sag Harbor Open for Tours Saturdays & Sundays through October 12

    Custom House Sag Harbor
    Tomorrow, 11 am

    Greenport Harbor Brewing Company Presents Contemporary Artist Gavin Zeigler

    Greenport Harbor Brewing Company’s Greenport Tasting Room
    Tomorrow, noon

    Oscar Molina Unveils Collaborative Artist Guestbook Canvas at Keyes Art Gallery

    Keyes Art Gallery
    Tomorrow, 1 pm

    Chowdah Chowdown 2025 – benefiting Springs Food Pantry

    Springs Tavern and Grill
    Oct 11, noon
    Dan’s Papers

    The iconic mainstay of Long Island’s East End for over 60 years.

    Read Our Papers

    Digital Editions of Dan’s Papers are available online.
    Get our best stories right into your inbox. Subscribe
    Follow us
    © Dan’s Papers 2025 Schneps Media |
    Designed by Digital Silk
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy

    Post an Event